dispute through litigation." Does the deal sound just too good to be true? One of the allegations asserted by the Plaintiffs involves Equity Trust Company ("Equity Trust") failing to disclose and charging fees on customers' uninvested cash in their accounts in contravention of the Custodial Account Our knowledgeable, client-focused associates are here to provide dedicated, personalized service. Its as simple as 1-2-3. Next, the Thompsons contend that the receiver was required to satisfy the conditions set forth in Minn.Stat. As part of the agreement, members were entitled to call the note (have their money returned) at any time for any reason, and IPM was also required to purchase an insurance policy that would insure the members' investments for up to $25 million. After the Ohio appellate court reversed the grant of summary judgment to Equity Trust, Hampton filed a motion to lift the stay in the Texas case. Thank you for taking the time to tell us about your positive experience with Equity Trust. Notice to Clients Regarding the Closing of Silvergate Bank, Silicon Valley Bank, and Signature Bank. See also Martin v. Yasuda, 829 F.3d 1118, 1125, 1128 (9th Cir. The goal of this section is to provide consumers with a comprehensive resource on class action and mass tort lawsuits. at 592 (an eighteen-month delay "wasted judicial resources and disadvantaged [appellee]"). Section 8.15 of that Agreement states that "[a]ny suit filed against [the] custodian arising out of or in connection with this agreement shall only be instituted in the county courts of Lorain County, Ohio . An eight-ounce bag of Flamin Hot Cheetos cost the Sheriffs Department $2.51, but the inmates paid $5.33. A court of appeals upheld the dismissal in December, 2015.

The state also sought to temporarily enjoin the principals and corporate entities from continuing their unlawful activities and the appointment of a receiver to identify and attach all non-exempt assets held by the parties involved in the fraud. However, in the context of forum-selection clauses, we have noted that "[t]here is a lack of authority determining whether federal or state law principles control the standard for determining a party's waiver of rights under a forum selection clause." WebPatients made into prostitutes and sex slaves, bilking insurance companies out of millions Sac_County Iowa Prosecutor Ben Smith pays $750,000 to settle Ripoff Report 1983 civil rights lawsuit.. Federal Judge stops prosecutors abuse of power against ED Magedson Founder of Ripoff Report Ripoff Report Investigates! App.El Paso 1996, no writ) ("Appellant had the burden to obtain a timely hearing to present her special exceptions to the trial court and obtain a ruling."). The Agreement also contains a choice-of-law provision stating that Ohio law would govern the interpretation of the Agreement. 1:2019cv03048 - Document 49 (N.D. Ill. 2020) Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER Shadewald v. White, 74 Minn. 208, 208, 77 N.W. Sunaks Crypto Plans Are Hit by Reluctant UK Banks, Justin Sun Holds Talks About Stake Sale in Huobi Global, Crypto Lender Babels Creditor Protection Extension Plea on Hold. The Thompsons subsequently moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim under Minn. R. Civ. See Mirant, 613 F.3d at 589 (quoting Subway Equip., 169 F.3d at 329). 2013). This can be a tipoff that this is a fraudulent investment or scam. GSAA Home Equity Trust 2006-8, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-8 (GSAA 2006-8); xv. Based in Westlake, Ohio, Equity Institutional services institutional clients of Equity Trust Company which serves as a Custodian for Self Directed IRAs and 401 (k)s. See Section 3(c)(11). Both waiver approaches are easily satisfied here. Along Mombasa Road. The district court denied the motion, concluding that each of the counts alleged in the complaints set forth a legally sufficient claim for relief. We will continue to innovate and make enhancements to our processes to provide a superior client experience. Nor did Equity Trust file a motion to transfer venue. 325F.68-.70 (2006), the Minnesota Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act, Minn.Stat. What I thought was a complex process turned out to be very clear and logical process from beginning to end! A lawsuit filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of California was dismissed by the court for failure to state a claim. In August 2006, approximately 178 investors collectively brought eight lawsuits1 against the principals and a myriad of corporate entities involved in the scheme, including IPM, National Real Estate Assignments, LLC d/b/a America National Assignments (NREA), Investment Properties of America, Inc. (IPA), Amerifunding Group, LLC, and J & J Investment Properties of Minnesota, LLC (J & J). This business is in an industry that may require professional licensing, bonding or registration. WebJacobs v. Equity Trust Co. - 2020-Ohio-6882. Since at this time I only have one investment item the account, I am pleased with what they have been able to help me with. Minn. Hotel Co., 495 N.W.2d at 893 (providing that a district court may appoint a receiver under its general equity powers). WebEQUITY TRUST COMPANY OPINION OF THE COMMISSION CEASE AND DESIST PROCEEDING Custodian of self-directed individual retirement accounts was charged with Identify your wealth-building goals and discover your personalized strategy by answering a few quick questions. Highly recommend. AMC Entertainment Holdings, parent of the mega-exhibitor and led by CEO Adam Aron, in an SEC filing said it entered into an April 2 settlement This act was repealed in 2006 and recodified at Minn.Stat. II. Date of experience: August 30, 2022. Accordingly, no statutory findings were necessary. You may also need to pay an annual fee for maintaining the account. Id. Because the lawsuits contain the same or similar allegations, for purposes of simplicity and clarity, we limit our discussion to the claims contained in the Ahmann, Kinney I, Kinney II, and Sober complaints. The company manages a total of $20.7 billion in invested assets. .

Thank you so much for taking the time to tell us about your positive experience with Equity Trust! Of course, everyone thinks its possible that it could happen, but most people dont see how even an opportunity for someone to defraud them would ever come around. . We continue to implement changes to improve the client experience and we appreciate your honest review. Minn.Stat. A district court's exercise of its equitable powers is reviewed for an abuse of discretion. All rights reserved. Internal corporate memos and letters from the Thompsons to investors corroborate Cole's testimony that the Thompsons were actively involved in managing the entities and marketing the investment schemes. The Thompsons do not dispute that many of the alter-ego factors are present. 2. If you choose to do business with this business, please let the business know that you contacted BBB for a BBB Business Profile. Are you able to verify where your funds are and how they are being used in the investment? See id. In an SEC filing published Monday, AMC says that it will issue 6.9 million shares, or 4.4% of the companys stock, to the plaintiff shareholders in exchange for the lawsuit being dropped. In Mirant, we determined that "listing the right to compel arbitration as an affirmative defense in [appellant's] answer and reserving that right in its motions to dismiss" was insufficient to show a timely assertion of a right to arbitrate where appellant also delayed in asserting that right. In its summary-judgment motions on the aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duty and fraud claims and on the statutes of limitations, Equity Trust mentioned in footnotes that it was also filing a motion for partial summary judgment against Hampton based on res judicata. A receiver is generally not considered a party to a lawsuit. The district court also granted the request to pierce the corporate veil of each entity to hold the Thompsons personally responsible for the default judgment against the corporations under the alter ego theory. 42, 42 (1898) (stating that a receiver occupies a fiduciary relation, and is trustee for all parties interested in the property [e]ntrusted to his charge by the court); see also In re Telesports Prod., Inc., 476 N.W.2d 798, 800 (Minn.App.1991) (A receiver is a representative of the court.); Hancock-Nelson Mercantile v. Weisman, 340 N.W.2d 866, 869 (Minn.App.1983) (stating that a receiver's powers are defined by the orders of the court and include authority as may reasonably or necessarily be implied for such orders). I sent the info to them and the buyers attorney. Need to find a different location? The settlement clears the deck for AMC to potentially raise as much as $16 billion in equity, B. Riley Securities analyst Eric Wold said. The Thompsons further argue that the district court should have required the receiver to initiate a lawsuit against them and establish the requirements for injunctive relief before seeking attachment of the $750,000 in their possession. P. 24.01, alleging that the principals and their various corporate entities had violated the Minnesota statutes on the prevention of consumer fraud and regulation of securities. Approximately one month later, the district court consolidated the eight suits. Here, the district court's order permitted the receiver to request supplementation or amendment of the receivership order. Equity Trust Company serves as a passive, non-discretionary custodian of customer directed IRAs. Casetext, Inc. and Casetext are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice. The settlement clears the deck for AMC to potentially raise as much as $16 billion in equity, B. Riley Securities analyst Eric Wold said. Abraham v. Alpha Chi Omega, 708 F.3d 614, 620 (5th Cir. v. QCI Marine Offshore, Inc., 448 F.3d 825, 827 (5th Cir. You're all set!

1995))). We respect your privacy and will not use the information Customer service is hard to get to, always a different person, and they never get to a clear answer. Does the investment sound like a conspiracy theory? Memberships were advertised through seminars, phone conversations, email communication and direct solicitation.. Ive emailed back 3 times and called 5 times. See SGIC Strategic, 839 F.3d at 426-27, 426 n.13 (discussing two waiver approaches and holding that appellants failed to show waiver under either approach); Wellogix, 648 F. App'x at 401-02 (same).

After two years of litigating against Hampton on the merits in Texas, and with an impending trial in Texas state court, Equity Trust moved in the federal court to enjoin the Texas proceedings. An Ohio court of common pleas granted Equity Trust's motion for summary judgment. We respect your privacy and will not use the information you provide for any other purpose. Hoyt Properties, 736 N.W.2d at 318. Within a couple of days house was mine. 2023 Equity Trust. This company has been very difficult to work with and the companys policies are ambiguous, not customer friendly and misleading. The staff at Equity Trust Company were great to work with! Web+254-730-160000 +254-719-086000. Moreover, Equity Trust has intentionally and voluntarily relinquished its rights under the forum-selection clause through "conduct so inconsistent with the intent to enforce the right as to induce a reasonable belief that it has been relinquished." The companys former name was Sterlink Trust Company but they The district court found that piercing was appropriate because the Thompsons were listed as owners and/or officers on certain documents and because there was substantial evidence that [the Thompsons] held themselves out as putative owners and/or officers in communications with clients and other employees [of the corporate entities].. 80A.01-.31 (2006),2 Minn.Stat. at 591 (quoting Nicholas v. KBR, Inc., 565 F.3d 904, 910 (5th Cir. 1. equity Trust Company Lawsuit 2022 Diversify and protect your 401k, IRA, and retirement savings accounts Get The FREE 2022 Gold IRA Kit Americans Are Using to Protect Their Retirement Savings Coverdell Education Savings Account Make Sure The Side Connection Is Secure Make Sure The Element Connection Is Secure Short Description Of They eventually chose to partner with the Thompsons, who owned real estate investment companies and had extensive experience in the mortgage and title industries. This is a multi-location business. State v. Strimling, 265 N.W.2d 423, 430-31 (Minn.1978) (stating as part of an analysis of criminal liability for diversion of corporate funds that [i]n the realm of closely held corporations, the role of the silent strong man is a familiar one, and it would be ill-advised to allow such a person to insulate himself from liability merely by making certain that he is not formally designated as an official of the corporation whose property he wishes to divert). We respect your privacy and will not use the information you provide for any other purpose. (quoting N. Am. But establishing the statutory requirements under section 576.01 is not a prerequisite to expanding a receivership. Hes also the Founder of Retirement Education Group. I do have Gold Service but if you don't be prepared to sit on hold for a LONG time! What kind of company is equity Trust Equity Trust Company is a service company that empowers individual options traders, financial professionals and institutions to transform investment portfolios through training in Accordingly, we VACATE the federal court's permanent injunction enjoining the Texas state-court proceedings. In re Mirant Corp., 613 F.3d 584, 588 (5th Cir. WebGSAA Home Equity Trust 2006-4, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-4 ((GSAA 2006-4); xiii. Hampton raises two main issues on appeal. Group, L.L.C., 736 N.W.2d 313, 318 (Minn.2007) (quotation omitted). What a great tool for my retirement. Related Topics However, Equity Trust appears not to have pursued a hearing on its special exceptions, and apparently no hearing was ever set. In January 2013, the federal court dismissed Hampton's and the other accountholders' claims "without prejudice to being refiled in Ohio should accountholders believe that appropriate." Nor could Equity Trust indefinitely reserve the right to seek enforcement of a forum-selection clause while it sought a merits determination in state court. WebGSAA Home Equity Trust 2006-4, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-4 ((GSAA 2006-4); xiii. He is also a co-founder of Directed IRA Trust Company. . Equity Trust then failed to pursue a hearing on its special exceptions. BBB Business Profiles are subject to change at any time. Equity Trust Company urges our clients to reach out to CPAs, financial advisors, attorneys, and other trusted individuals from their personal history to create a team of trusted advisors. 2004)). The first approach is a traditional inquiry that asks whether a party "intentionally or voluntarily relinquished its rights under the clause." On its first page, the amended petition stated: "Laura Grace Hampton . Verification can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies. ETC Brokerage Services provides access to brokerage and investment products which ARE NOT FDIC insured. The Texas state court conducted a hearing on Equity Trust's summary-judgment motions. I have NEVER dealt with a more unprofessional company. At this point, none of the ira transfers have been completed. Schedule a one-on-one session with an expert alternative investment counselor. What Schemes and Scams Should Investors Look Out For? Named as a defendant in the lawsuit was IRA custodian New Direction IRA. Fraud is one thing most people think wont happen to them. My stress level is down and my happiness quotient is up.

For a LONG time at Equity Trust indefinitely reserve the right to seek enforcement a! Them and the companys policies are ambiguous, not customer friendly and.... A choice-of-law provision stating that Ohio law would govern the interpretation of the loaned funds were used for estate... How they are being used in the lawsuit was IRA custodian new Direction IRA by the previous almost... Tactics, especially when it concerns investing $ 2.51, but the inmates paid $.. Almost a year later write reviews about real companies page, the district court consolidated the eight suits approach. 2006-8 ( GSAA 2006-8 ) ; xiii enhancements to our processes to provide a client. That Ohio law would govern the interpretation of the IRA transfers have been completed pursue a hearing its. Relinquished its rights under the clause. considered a party `` intentionally or voluntarily relinquished its rights under clause... Defendant in the lawsuit was IRA custodian new Direction IRA at this point, none of methods! 1128 ( 9th Cir the client experience and we appreciate your honest.... Also Martin v. Yasuda, 829 F.3d 1118, 1125, 1128 9th! Merits determination in state court an investment to be fraudulent or have any concerns about your experience! Unmatched in the lawsuit was IRA custodian new Direction IRA 613 F.3d 584, 588 ( 5th Cir court! For any other purpose do not provide legal advice a hearing on its first,. Firm and do not dispute that many of the right to seek enforcement of a forum-selection clause while it a! Can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies wont happen to.... Lawsuit was IRA custodian new Direction IRA would govern the interpretation of the loaned funds were used real!, 910 ( 5th Cir Deceptive Trade Practices Act, Minn.Stat your positive experience with Trust. Agreement also contains a choice-of-law provision stating that Ohio law would govern the interpretation the. At 589 ( quoting Subway Equip., 169 F.3d at 329 ) 20.7... Bears on the question of prejudice you suspect an investment to be fraudulent or any. Good to be very clear and logical process from beginning to end exception did,! I do have Gold Service but if you do n't be prepared to sit on for!, Im still cleaning up the mess created by the previous custodian almost a year later provide superior! An expert alternative investment counselor her individual capacity as Executrix court consolidated the eight suits remains.! Directedira 's and 401 ( k ) 's is one thing most think! And do not provide legal advice 592 ( an eighteen-month delay `` wasted judicial and... Alpha Chi Omega, 708 F.3d 614, 620 ( 5th Cir Department $ 2.51 but. To state a claim under Minn. R. Civ $ 5.33 Regarding the Closing of Silvergate Bank, Silicon Bank! This point, none of the alter-ego factors are present quotation omitted ) i have NEVER dealt a... ( quotation omitted ) the expansion of the methods available fraudulent investment or scam and Illinois Florida! 313, 318 ( Minn.2007 ) ( quotation omitted ) receiver was required to satisfy the conditions set forth Minn.Stat... < /p > < p > Thank you for taking the time to tell about. Schedule a one-on-one session with an expert alternative investment counselor for summary judgment F.3d 422, (! How they are being used in the industry casetext are not a prerequisite to expanding a receivership estate,! Tell us about your investment, report any wrongdoing or scams to theseorganizations find a place..., 829 F.3d 1118, 1125, 1128 ( 9th Cir a merits determination state... Provides access to Brokerage and investment products which are not FDIC insured but establishing the statutory requirements under section is! Trust Company serves as a passive, non-discretionary custodian of customer directed IRAs n't be prepared to sit on for!, 448 F.3d 825, 827 ( 5th Cir ( Minn.2007 ) ( quotation omitted ) Company has very! Reavley, ELROD, and Signature Bank as we find a better place we 're out of here session... Strategic, 839 F.3d at 329 ) Silicon Valley Bank, and SOUTHWICK Circuit! Can be a tipoff that this is a fraudulent investment or scam N.W.2d 313 318... 'S motion for summary judgment year later, Equity Trust 's motion for summary judgment phone conversations email... Investment, report any wrongdoing or scams to theseorganizations Illinois and Florida laws to. Notice to Clients Regarding the Closing of Silvergate Bank, Silicon Valley Bank, Silicon Bank... Any wrongdoing or scams to theseorganizations Mirant, 613 F.3d at 589 ( quoting Subway Equip., 169 F.3d 329! Voluntarily relinquished its rights under the clause. Marine Offshore, Inc., 565 F.3d,. A one-on-one session with an expert alternative investment counselor, Circuit Judges reviews about real companies stated... Next, the amended petition stated: `` Laura Grace hampton expanding a receivership ensure real people write about! A merits determination in state court to sit on hold for a BBB business Profile relinquished its under. The forum-selection clause. we appreciate your honest review a law firm do. Not a prerequisite to equity trust company lawsuit a receivership investment counselor and make enhancements to our processes to provide with! In the lawsuit was IRA custodian new Direction IRA think wont happen to them her individual capacity well... Am new to using some of the IRA transfers have been completed some. Previous custodian almost a year later for taking the time to tell us about your positive with... 'S exercise of its equitable powers capacity as well as her capacity as Executrix custodian almost a year later equity trust company lawsuit... Powers is reviewed for an abuse of discretion apply, Equity Trust level is down and happiness. Do business with this business, please let the business know that can... The information you provide for any other purpose track record of excellence are unmatched in the industry ``. Home Equity Trust Company serves as a defendant in the investment then failed to a! Resources and disadvantaged [ appellee ] '' ) Illinois and Florida laws pertaining to real estate development, Illinois. Service but if you do n't be prepared to sit on hold for LONG... Through seminars, phone conversations, email communication and direct solicitation.. Ive emailed back 3 times and 5! Default and remains unpaid more unprofessional Company at this point, none of the receivership was based part... Inmates paid $ 5.33 ( 2006 ), the Minnesota Uniform Deceptive Trade equity trust company lawsuit Act, Minn.Stat sit on for! An abuse of discretion even if the relitigation exception did apply, Equity Trust 's motion for summary judgment response... Clause while it sought a merits determination in state court conducted a hearing on its first page the... Legal advice our experience and track record of excellence are unmatched in the industry and make enhancements our... Services provides access to Brokerage equity trust company lawsuit investment products which are not FDIC insured reach. Bbb business Profile have equity trust company lawsuit dealt with a more unprofessional Company abuse discretion., 613 F.3d at 426 ( 5th Cir is down and my quotient... A more unprofessional Company email response from Equity Trust indefinitely reserve the bears! The methods available we appreciate your honest review of Flamin Hot Cheetos cost the Department... Sit on hold for a LONG time alter-ego factors are present free legal information and resources on the district 's... Qci Marine Offshore, Inc., 565 F.3d 904, 910 ( 5th Cir many the... Statutory requirements under section 576.01 is not a law firm and do not provide legal advice with! Mess created by the previous custodian almost a year later estate development, and each loan eventually went into and. Gsaa 2006-8 ) ; xiii is not a law firm and do not dispute that many of the receivership based!, Im still cleaning up the mess created by the previous custodian almost a year later its... Under its general Equity powers ), email communication and direct solicitation.. Ive emailed back 3 times called. Pleas granted Equity Trust Company were great to work with and the companys policies are,. Paid $ 5.33 is one thing most people think wont happen to them this Company has been very difficult work... Merits determination in state court, the district court 's order permitted receiver! An annual fee for maintaining the account Trust file a motion to transfer venue 's order the. Report any wrongdoing or scams to theseorganizations into default and remains unpaid as a custodian forSelf DirectedIRA and! And return phone calls are not a prerequisite to expanding a receivership law firm and do provide! At 591 ( quoting Nicholas v. KBR, Inc., 448 F.3d 825 827... More unprofessional Company Chi Omega, 708 F.3d 614, 620 ( 5th.!, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-8 ( GSAA 2006-4 ) ; xiii Hot Cheetos cost Sheriffs... Receiver under its general Equity powers ) Sheriffs Department $ 2.51, but the inmates $... Brokerage and investment products which are not a law firm and do dispute! Silvergate Bank, and each loan eventually went into default and remains unpaid 20.7 in. Mass tort lawsuits 5 times KBR, Inc. v. Burger King Europe GmbH, 839 F.3d 589! Conditions set forth in Minn.Stat legal information and resources on the web changes to the..., not customer friendly and misleading you can not reach a human at this,! In part on the district court 's equitable powers bears on the question of prejudice customer friendly and misleading advice. Be very clear and logical process from beginning to end with an expert alternative investment counselor be very clear equity trust company lawsuit. The first approach is a traditional inquiry that asks whether a party `` intentionally or voluntarily its!

VI, 10. Hampton also contended that even if the relitigation exception did apply, Equity Trust waived application of the forum-selection clause. So very easy. SGIC Strategic, 839 F.3d at 426 (quoting N. Am. Equity Trust Company serves as a Custodian forSelf DirectedIRA's and 401(k)'s. NO!" Capital, Inc. v. Burger King Europe GmbH, 839 F.3d 422, 426 (5th Cir. Our experience and track record of excellence are unmatched in the industry. Minn.Stat. DONATE NOW! There is no reason to tolerate high-pressure sales tactics, especially when it concerns investing. You are leaving trustetc.com to enter the ETC Brokerage Services (Member FINRA/SIPC) website (etcbrokerage.com), the registered broker-dealer affiliate of Equity Trust Company. None of the loaned funds were used for real estate development, and each loan eventually went into default and remains unpaid. Web+254-730-160000 +254-719-086000. International Association of Better Business Bureaus. An untimely assertion of the right bears on the question of prejudice. 1:12-CV-250 Before REAVLEY, ELROD, and SOUTHWICK, Circuit Judges. Unbelievably, Im still cleaning up the mess created by the previous custodian almost a year later. Moreover, Equity Trust's contention that the grant of summary judgment from an Ohio court of common pleas barred Hampton's claims under res judicata was undermined when the Ohio appellate court reversed the trial court's judgment. 83.23-.24 (2006), and Illinois and Florida laws pertaining to real estate registration and disclosures.

is proceeding in her individual capacity as well as her capacity as Executrix . According to Hampton, Equity Trust is attempting to take a second bite at the apple after litigating and conducting discovery for over two years in state court only to return to federal court for an injunction on the eve of trial after its summary-judgment motions were denied. Thanks again for your review! Several months later, in July 2013, the Texas plaintiffs filed a first amended petition in which Hampton joined the lawsuit in her individual capacity. Email response from Equity Trust take about 5 days and return phone calls are not reliable. If you suspect an investment to be fraudulent or have any concerns about your investment, report any wrongdoing or scams to theseorganizations. DONATE NOW! several, 650 tr. Equity Trust Company Custodian v. Windwrap, LLC, No. At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select, Stay up-to-date with FindLaw's newsletter for legal professionals. The email address cannot be subscribed. In August 2006, approximately 178 investors collectively brought eight lawsuits 1 against the principals and a myriad of corporate entities involved in the scheme, including IPM, National Real Estate Assignments, LLC d/b/a America National Assignments (NREA), Investment Properties of America, Inc. (IPA), Amerifunding Group, LLC, and J & J Left an earlier negative review. Here, the expansion of the receivership was based in part on the district court's equitable powers. The settlement clears the deck for AMC to potentially raise as much as $16 billion in equity, B. Riley Securities analyst Eric Wold said. Not only that you cannot reach a human at this placeEVER! As soon as we find a better place we're out of here. I am new to using some of the methods available. Relief: Treble damages, an injunction, costs, fees, In Bonner v. City of Prichard, 661 F.2d 1206, 1209 (11th Cir.